Nicholas Restaurant

85 East Central Street
Natick, MA 01760
Tel: 508-655-7878

 

History Services Reviews Our Guests
We are so proud... Great article and critique. Thank you, guests and please tell your friends!
"Globe West"
BOSTON SUNDAY GLOBE OCTOBER 3, 2004

Dining out at Nicholas Restuarant

Author: STEPHANIE CALLAHAN

Nicholas Restaurant opened just seven months ago, but the owners are not new to the business. For 25 years, Nick Stournaras and his family ran Nick's Ice Cream, a Natick institution famous for its fried seafood and homemade ice cream.

The old Nick's, which resembled a Cape Cod clam shack, was torn down and replaced by a beautiful restaurant, but the commitment to quality food remains just on a more expanded, upscale level.

Nick's son, John, and John's wife, Sharon, run the restaurant now, but the family patriarch is still very much a presence greeting and seating customers, delivering food orders when it's busy, and chatting with patrons like the host of a dinner party.

John Stournaras, who works in the kitchen with the head chef, said the menu incorporates a lot of the items that made the old Nick's famous, along with healthier, non-fried options.

The dining room is light and airy and painted a lovely shade of yellow, ! with chandeliers and huge vases of flowers. The front dining area is a little more intimate, and especially pretty with its Mediterranean-style muraled wall and big picture windows. There's a small full-service bar with a TV, where you can also eat.

The menu includes fried, grilled, and broiled seafood; chicken and beef; baked lasagna; ribs; and a handful of Greek specialties like moussaka ($11), Greek lemon soup ($2 a cup, $3 a bowl), and lamb. The lunch menu boasts a nice variety of sandwiches; burgers and wraps; clam and scallop rolls; fish and chips; and lower-priced versions of some of the dinner entrees.

The fried food truly lived up to its reputation. The calamari appetizer ($7) was golden and crispy, with a light batter that didn't overwhelm the squid's brininess. And we liked how the succulent fried shrimp were prepared: deveined, butterflied, and deep-fried in a crunchy batter that kept the shrimp sweet and soft inside ($8 as an appetizer, $14 for a ! dinner).

The hand-cut onion rings ($3.50) were golden and light , not greasy or overbattered. Even the potato skins appetizer ($6), filled with crispy bacon and mozzarella cheese, managed to escape the grease factor.

Portions are generous and come with a house salad, choice of rice, potato, or pasta, and a vegetable. Cole slaw, onion rings, french fries, and salad are served with all fried entrees.

Lamb is a staple in traditional Greek cooking, so we tried the roasted leg ($15) and highly recommend it. The sliced meat was lean and tender, enhanced with a savory brown gravy. Fresh green beans and heavenly roasted potato wedges accompanied the lamb.

The chicken parmesan ($12) was another good choice and covered the entire plate. The poultry was lightly breaded and topped with a zesty, house-made marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese.

Dry-rubbed baby back ribs were indeed juicy and tender and slathered with a tangy, smoky barbecue sauce ($15 for a full rack; $10 for half).

The grilled lemon pepper Atlantic ! salmon fillet ($14) was fresh, flaky, and moist and came drizzled with a mild bearnaise sauce.

The service at Nick's is cordial and efficient, the food tastes homemade, and you won't be hit with a hefty tab.

If you can't get a baby sitter, bring the kids: They are welcome at Nicholas. The children's menu includes pasta with marinara or butter, chicken fingers, kid's fish, and burgers with french fries, all for less than $5, including a soft drink.

On neither of our visits did we have room for dessert, but the list includes tiramisu, cheesecake, chocolate truffle cake, ice cream, and the house specialty gallotobouriko, a traditional Greek dessert of custard wrapped in phyllo dough topped with sweet syrup. All desserts are $2.75-$5.50.

"When people come into our restaurant, we want them to feel like they are coming into our home," said John Stournaras.

On both occasions, that's just how we felt.